English Arts Festival
Discussion Board: Reef of Death


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 10:39:57
Author: Wilson, Sandra <SWi3548332@aol.com>
Subject: Discussion Questions 

1. Why do you think Reef of Death has such a wide appeal for middle school students?

2. Comment on the theme of free choice in Reef of Death.
(See pages 54-55)

3. Do you think that the violence in Reef of Death is gratuitous or does it serve a purpose?

4. Does Zindel depict adult characters differently than his younger characters? Explain.

5. Does Zindel give an accurate portrayal of a teenager's thoughts and feelings? 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 10:52:00
Author: Wilson, Sandra <SWi3548332@aol.com>
Subject: Re: Discussion Questions 

Sorry I posted these three times. I had a computer glitch.

Sandra 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 13:15:28
Author: Pinkstock, Theresa <terrip@amanda.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Re: Discussion Questions 

Regarding question #2, the theme of free choice, I feel as though consequences have actions and the choices you make will result in a consequence, positive or negative. According to PC and Maruul's conversation, I think PC wants to think that people do bad things because of the Devil or demons make them do it. PC and Maruul touch on the subject of God and the Devil, and their role in our decision making. As I tell my children and students, there is a vast amount of information and things for us to do in life. What we do with it is our choice based on the knowledge of the consequences of our actions.  


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 14:37:00
Author: Hayden, Kellie <khayden@loganhocking.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Re: Discussion Questions 

I like your questions and agreee that my 8th grade students will like this book.

I also think that much of the violence is not necessary.

Can we have one more nasty female antagonist who is figured after his mother???? 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 14:37:55
Author: Hayden, Kellie <khayden@loganhocking.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Re: Discussion Questions 

I like your questions and agreee that my 8th grade students will like this book.

I also think that much of the violence is not necessary.

Can we have one more nasty female antagonist who is figured after his mother???? 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 10:40:00
Author: Wilson, Sandra <SWi3548332@aol.com>
Subject: Discussion Questions 

1. Why do you think Reef of Death has such a wide appeal for middle school students?

2. Comment on the theme of free choice in Reef of Death.
(See pages 54-55)

3. Do you think that the violence in Reef of Death is gratuitous or does it serve a purpose?

4. Does Zindel depict adult characters differently than his younger characters? Explain.

5. Does Zindel give an accurate portrayal of a teenager's thoughts and feelings? 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 12:11:11
Author: Pinkstock, Theresa <terrip@amanda.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Re: Discussion Questions 

First of All, great job on the questions!!!!!!! In response to question #1, I think this story appeals to students because it is full of gory details and it's suspenseful. Some students love these kind of stories for that reason. I am and have been a fan for horror novels.  


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 10:40:05
Author: Wilson, Sandra <SWi3548332@aol.com>
Subject: Discussion Questions 

1. Why do you think Reef of Death has such a wide appeal for middle school students?

2. Comment on the theme of free choice in Reef of Death.
(See pages 54-55)

3. Do you think that the violence in Reef of Death is gratuitous or does it serve a purpose?

4. Does Zindel depict adult characters differently than his younger characters? Explain.

5. Does Zindel give an accurate portrayal of a teenager's thoughts and feelings? 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 12:34:12
Author: Pinkstock, Theresa <terrip@amanda.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Connector, The Reef of Death 

This story connects to my life in a few ways:
1. PC describes his fear of water. He states that, although, he is afraid of being eaten everytime he goes in the water, he still goes. I can understand and relate to this fear. I have always had a fear of water. Even though I am afraid of it, I still have learned how to swim. I still do somethings in water, like swim; however, I really have no desire to water ski. I do not like to swim in lakes because I can't see what is in the water around me. I know-- I am weird.
2. Another way I connected to the story was when Wally was captured in the torture chair, and Dr. Ecenbarger released the poisonous fish in the tank with him. He observed how beautiful the fish was. I, too, remember going snorkling and seeing brightly colored, beautiful fish around me. I was in awe of how beautiful they were; but, I was also scared because I was afraid of what they would do.
3. Lastly, I felt a connection with this story when Wally and Maruul spoke of the opal wall and the tribal paintings depicting their cultural heritage. Both of them spoke of spoke of the importance of preserving their heritage. I, too, feel a sense of responsiblility to preserve history and my heritage. I tend to hold on to items that have been handed down through my family, whether the value is monetary or emotional. My husband calls me a pack rat. However, as I grow older, I feel as though I can hold on to the past by preserving some of these items. 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 14:40:21
Author: Hayden, Kellie <khayden@loganhocking.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Re: Connector, The Reef of Death 

Yes, I am a pack rat too. Keeping "junk" for posterity is my middle name. So, I can too relate to the heritage theme in this book as well.

I also connected to PC and his dysfunctual family. It all starts when the family stops playing together, no more board games. 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 14:59:00
Author: Hayden, Kellie <khayden@loganhocking.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Summarizing Reef of Dath 

This book takes PC, the aboriginal girl Maruul and his uncle Cliff to a exciting adventure. PC walks into another scheme of his uncle's that offers a wild summer ride and his untimely death.There is action, gore, sea monsters, evil characters, and suspense.

The nasty Dr. Ecenbarger is illegally mining off a sacred reef in Australia. She has set up a spoof lab, which is just a food holding tank for the nasty huge sea creature with teeth like knives. She uses this sea creature to scare her subjects into submission. These hench men are also under the orders of a rouge man from Maruul's tribe. The sea creature, which responds to a wistle at her command, has already killed Maruul's brother and Cliff.

Towards the end, Ecenbarger's greed for the huge Opal almost sends PC and Wally, an old tribe member, to their death. Maruul was kept by the evil doctor in a monkey cage for the exotic slave trade. With PC's quick thinking and many set backs to the escape, he uses his laptop to escape. The battery starts an explosion from the magnesium already mined in the shaft.

In the end, Maruul's tribe gets some of the opal to keep its land. PC decides to go home to the U.S. and reunite with his family.

 


Current Forum: Reef of Death
Date: 14-Jan-2003 14:59:19
Author: Hayden, Kellie <khayden@loganhocking.k12.oh.us>
Subject: Summarizing Reef of Dath 

This book takes PC, the aboriginal girl Maruul and his uncle Cliff to a exciting adventure. PC walks into another scheme of his uncle's that offers a wild summer ride and his untimely death.There is action, gore, sea monsters, evil characters, and suspense.

The nasty Dr. Ecenbarger is illegally mining off a sacred reef in Australia. She has set up a spoof lab, which is just a food holding tank for the nasty huge sea creature with teeth like knives. She uses this sea creature to scare her subjects into submission. These hench men are also under the orders of a rouge man from Maruul's tribe. The sea creature, which responds to a wistle at her command, has already killed Maruul's brother and Cliff.

Towards the end, Ecenbarger's greed for the huge Opal almost sends PC and Wally, an old tribe member, to their death. Maruul was kept by the evil doctor in a monkey cage for the exotic slave trade. With PC's quick thinking and many set backs to the escape, he uses his laptop to escape. The battery starts an explosion from the magnesium already mined in the shaft.

In the end, Maruul's tribe gets some of the opal to keep its land. PC decides to go home to the U.S. and reunite with his family.